Lisa Fay Bakes

Creating cookie flavors you didn't know you craved.

The Bakery will be on a Summer Break from August 6-21. Reach out with any questions!

Cookie Flavors

*(V) Indicates Vegan (dairy & egg free) / All cookies are made without nuts or soy products

Click on the "Flavors" tab for detailed descriptions.

Brown Butter

Chocolate Chip

Lemon Rosemary Shortbread

Double Chocolate Chunk (V)

Chewy Tahini Sesame (V)

Blueberry Cornbread

Cookie (V)

Coconut Lavender

Sugar Cookie (V)

Sea Salt Chocolate Chip (V)

Apple Cider

Snickerdoodle (V)

Fruity Pebbles Sugar

Cookie (V)

Chocolate Pretzel Shortbread (V)

Cinnamon Roll Cookie with Maple Glaze (V)

Morning Oatmeal Cookie (V)

Flavor of the Month

Tasting Boxes

Order a tasting box to try all of our flavors!

You can choose the Small box (one of each flavor) or the Large box (two of each flavor).

Regular and Vegan boxes available.

Cookie Decorating Kits

DIY Cookie Cake Kit (serves 12-16)

Perfect for holidays and birthdays!

Comes with a 9.5 inch cake, coordinated frosting colors, and sprinkles! Can be shipped anywhere in the US!

Decorated Cookie Cakes are also available for local delivery

While efforts are made to avoid cross-contamination, all cookies are baked in a home kitchen that may contain allergens and on equipment with shared use.

See the Ingredients page for full details.

Sticker Options for Gift Boxes

Happy Birthday


Thinking of You


Pandemic Cookies

Just Because

Good Luck

Thank You

You Deserve Cookies

Happy Anniversary

Get Well Soon

Local Delivery & US Shipping Available


Lisa Fay Bakes is a licensed home bakery in the Philadelphia suburbs proudly serving crave-worthy cookies for any occasion. Order a box of cookies to say thank you, celebrate a birthday, or to let someone know you are thinking of them. Get yourself some because fresh home-baked cookies are always a good idea. Especially for breakfast.

Most of our cookies are vegan, but you wouldn't know it.

Go ahead and see for yourself.

Lisa Fay Bakes is owned and operated by Lisa Gaub. Lisa is also a Licensed Professional Counselor who turned to baking after being laid off due to the pandemic, allowing her hobby to grow into a business.

Lisa lives in Narberth with her husband, Andrew, and their daughters. They are all willing taste testers.